‘Did Mirasis make Pakistan?’ Sindh governor sparks backlash
Sindh governor sparks debate with ‘Mirasis’ remark
Sindh Governor Nehal Hashmi has sparked a social media debate after making remarks about music, dancing and “Mirasis” during an Independence Day event at the University of Karachi. Hashmi attended the university’s Azadi Fiesta on August 13 in his capacity as the Sindh governor.
A video clip of his remarks later circulated widely on social media platforms, including Instagram and Facebook. The comments drew attention to the way Independence Day celebrations are marked and triggered a wider discussion about the use of the term “Mirasi”.
“Did the Mirasis make Pakistan?”
In the viral video, Hashmi appears to point towards people playing the tabla and dancing during the event.
He then asks, “Did the Mirasis make Pakistan?”
Hashmi also questions whether Pakistan was created through dancing.
The video was widely reposted by Pakistani social media pages, where users shared different reactions to his remarks. Some criticised the comments, while others debated the nature of Independence Day celebrations and the governor’s use of the word “Mirasi”.
Remarks trigger wider social media discussion
The controversy has gone beyond a simple disagreement over music and dancing during Independence Day celebrations. Hashmi appeared to use the term “Mirasi” while criticising those involved in musical performances at the event.
His remarks have reopened discussions about social class, caste-based labels and the way cultural performers are viewed in society. The debate has also raised questions about whether people associated with music and other cultural traditions should be portrayed as less connected to Pakistan’s national identity.
Debate over Independence Day celebrations
Also Read: Pakistan, Norway agree to deepen security, migration ties
Independence Day celebrations in Pakistan often include flag displays, musical programmes, cultural events and other public activities. However, Hashmi’s remarks have drawn attention to differing views on which forms of celebration are appropriate for the national occasion.
The viral clip has become a talking point as users continue to discuss music, dance and cultural expression in connection with Independence Day events. The discussion has also highlighted how a short public statement can quickly trigger a broader debate when widely shared on social media.
Governor also calls for unity and tolerance
Interestingly, Hashmi also delivered a message of unity during the same gathering at the University of Karachi. He said Pakistan belonged to everyone and called for greater unity, tolerance and mutual respect among citizens.
This part of his speech has added another dimension to the debate surrounding his earlier remarks. While calling for unity, his comments about “Mirasis” have led some social media users to question the language used to criticise cultural performers.
Why the ‘Mirasis’ remark has drawn attention
The word “Mirasi” has traditionally been associated with communities connected to music, storytelling and other cultural traditions in South Asia. However, the term can also carry social and caste-related connotations, depending on how and in what context it is used.
Hashmi’s remarks have therefore triggered discussion not only about Independence Day celebrations but also about language, social identity and respect for cultural communities. The reaction shows how public comments involving social or cultural labels can quickly become the subject of wider debate.
